UBU Integral Development Studies
Subsections
Actions
- Delete
- Edit
- Reply
Comment by Linda Nowakowski
Author: Linda Nowakowski (189)
Date posted: Sat, 01 Dec 2007 23:34:45 PST
Comment on: Gross National Happiness Conference (0)
Feedback score: 0 +|-
Subjective
From Mirriam-Webster:
- Main Entry:
- 1 sub·jec·tive
- Pronunciation:
- (ˌ)səb-ˈjek-tiv
- Function:
- adjective
- Date:
- 15th century
1: of, relating to, or constituting a subject: as a obsolete : of, relating to, or characteristic of one that is a subject especially in lack of freedom of action or in submissiveness b: being or relating to a grammatical subject; especially : nominative
2: of or relating to the essential being of that which has substance, qualities, attributes, or relations
3 a: characteristic of or belonging to reality as perceived rather than as independent of mind : phenomenal — compare objective 1b
b: relating to or being experience or knowledge as conditioned by personal mental characteristics or states
4 a (1): peculiar to a particular individual : personal < subjective judgments> (2): modified or affected by personal views, experience, or background <a subjective account of the incident>
b: arising from conditions within the brain or sense organs and not directly caused by external stimuli < subjective sensations>
c: arising out of or identified by means of one's perception of one's own states and processes <a subjective symptom of disease> — compare objective 1c
5: lacking in reality or substance : illusory
— sub·jec·tive·ly adverb
— sub·jec·tive·ness noun
—sub·jec·tiv·i·ty -jek-ˈti-və-tē noun
I think that some are you are about to be subjected to your first exposure to my obsession with definitions.
When I was first exposed to the concept of Gross National Happiness, I thought it was a clever play on words. As I delved it to it more as a part of this research, I became disenamored with the term. Part of that came as a result of imprecise definitions. Part of it came from what I have a hard time calling anything but subjective as in 4a2 - modified or affected by personal views, experience, or background.
I have no problem subjective information. I have, in fact, come to rely on it more and more in the most important areas of my life. What I object to is (what appears to me to be) arbitrary "semi-quantitative" interpretation of subjective data. Interpretations that are not qualified with even a 'I believe that the following can be interpreted from the data.' The ratings of the Thai GNH survey have been used to indicate a measure of concern for the King![#] I am absolutely NOT saying that Thais' do not love and totally adore their King. But I can not see how the GNH poll can be specifically interpreted with that!
| [1] | http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/ main.jhtml?xml=/news/2007/11/30/ wthai130.xml |
Enrico Giovannini, the chief statistician for the OECD said "Some of these measures are based on solid statistical evidence, others on weak data or woolly methodologies." [#] If you have people answer on a scale of 1-5 how happy they are, of what use is the number? It may be accurate. It may be precise. It may be lots of things, but what does it mean and of what use is it?
| [2] | Giovannini, Enrico. Why measuring progress matters. July 2007 "A culture of evidence-based decision making has to be promoted at all levels, to increase the welfare of societies." [#] |
| [3] | Istanbul Declaration http://www.oecd.org/oecdworldfor um |
The Istanbul Agreement of 2007 really has hit it on the head. I believe it was Peter Drucker who said that if it can't be measured, it can't be managed. [#] If we want to manage development (and I can't believe that we don't) then we need to carefully define it and identify how to measure its aspects so that we can see if we are doing it right and where we are having successes and failures.
| [4] | http://www.thinkarete.com/quotes /by_topic/Age |
Save me from subjective results and ill defined words!
</rant>